Showing posts with label negative interest rate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label negative interest rate. Show all posts
Tuesday, February 23, 2016
Gold Wins by Default
The Japanese Yen was the biggest winner last week, surging despite negative fundamentals like the 0.4% decline in preliminary Japanese GDP for the fourth quarter. Despite all the gloom and doom, the Japanese yen has not only held its own against the strong US dollar, but posted a superb rally. How is this possible? Well, the Yen simply maximized its traditional safe-haven status, and global financial instability drove investors away from risk assets towards safer waters like the Japanese currency. The recent rush to safe assets will not last indefinitely however, and weak fundamentals will not fade away for this island country. Losers last week include, the Swiss Franc which experienced a retracement from the previous week’s gains.
On of this week’s major themes is the fact that an increasing number of central banks are employing negative rates – Europe, Denmark, Sweden, Switzerland and now Japan. What does it mean? And who’s next?
Well, negative rates signal slight desperation on the part of central banks. It suggests that traditional policy options were not effective and that new drastic measures are needed. Rates below zero also mean that there is minimal expectation of inflation and little to no anticipation of near-term economic rebound. How well negative interest rates have worked in the past is debatable, but most economists think they've had some success in Europe. Lowering rates has helped stem the appreciation of the Swedish and Swiss currencies and significantly pushed down the value of the Euro against the Dollar, which was a nice boost for exporters in the Euro Zone.
Well, negative rates signal slight desperation on the part of central banks. It suggests that traditional policy options were not effective and that new drastic measures are needed. Rates below zero also mean that there is minimal expectation of inflation and little to no anticipation of near-term economic rebound. How well negative interest rates have worked in the past is debatable, but most economists think they've had some success in Europe. Lowering rates has helped stem the appreciation of the Swedish and Swiss currencies and significantly pushed down the value of the Euro.
As for who is next, The Bank of Canada is the most likely of the major central banks to opt for negative rates this year, claims Marc Chandler, head of FX Markets Strategy at BBH. "I am not saying the Bank of Canada will, but that is the most likely candidate of those that are not there yet…” Canada's current overnight rate is already very low and the BOC has prepared markets for the possibility of negative rates by alluding to how they might work as a policy tool. Back in December, Stephen Poloz said the lower bound for the policy interest rate was around minus 0.5%. The bank will update its rate target on March 9.
In the US, it remains an open question whether the Fed will adopt negative rates in this environment. They seem to be enjoying a stronger economy than most, but everyone’s eyes will be on the data in coming weeks to see if it will warrant a drastic policy shift at the FOMC meeting in March. A change in economic circumstances could put negative rates “on the table” in the U.S., but unless the economy weakens significantly many analysts expect Fed policymakers to slowly raise rates, and not cut them. “I do not see this as anything but very low risk in the U.S." states Chandler.
In theory, rates below zero should reduce borrowing costs for companies and households, driving demand for loans. In practice however, a bank charging customers to hold their money, may cause cash to go under the mattress, or perhaps somewhere shinier...
It seems that the threat of negative rates across the globe has made Gold one of this year’s best investments. Negative rates, in simple terms, means that depositing cash will leave investors with less than when they started, making traditional assets such as gold more appealing. “Leave a million dollars with a bank, and in a year, you get only something like $990,000 back,” said Marc Faber, publisher of the Gloom, Boom & Doom Report. “I would rather want to own some solid currency, in other words gold.” All in all, when you have negative rates, something with a 0% yield becomes a high-yield asset and is therefore a nice place to park your money
Posted by
VBCE FX
at
4:25 PM
0
comments
Labels:
Bank of Canada,
Denmark,
Europe,
FOMC,
Gold,
Japanese Yen,
negative interest rate,
Sweden,
Switzerland
Tuesday, February 2, 2016
Five and Counting
At the end of last week’s blog post, we mentioned that the central banks of Japan, New Zealand, and the USA would deliver policy announcements. We went on to say that no moves were expected by all three banks but if there was to be a move it would come from the Reserve Bank of New Zealand. On this count, we were half correct. There was a surprise move but it came from Japan not New Zealand, more on that later.
The big surprise of the week was the Bank of Japan adopting negative interest rates. The BOJ will charge 0.1% on any cash left on deposit with the bank. The yen responded with a loss of almost 2% on the week. This move shocked the markets because only a week ago Bank of Japan Governor, Haruhiko Kuroda, told an audience at the Davos World Economic Forum that he would not adopt negative interest rates. The bank’s policymakers, who voted 5-4 to approve the measure, took great pains to say the rate cut was based on global conditions and not the Japanese economy itself. It makes you wonder what the BOJ has seen that has changed their minds so quickly. It also makes you wonder why the Fed’s policymakers are not seeing the same thing.
The BOJ’s latest move makes it five and counting – i.e. five central banks that currently have a negative interest rate policy. The others are the ECB (-0.3%), Denmark (-0.65%), Switzerland (-0.75) and Sweden (-1.1%). We are emphasizing “and counting” because we believe that eventually other western central banks, including the US Fed, will have no choice but to adopt negative interest rates.
There were some changes in last Wednesday’s FOMC statement. The FOMC removed the line about the economy “expanding at a moderate pace” and replaced it with “growth slowed late last year”. They warned that market based measures of inflation compensation “declined further” and that inflation is expected to “remain low in the near term, in part because of further declines in energy prices.” The FOMC also explicitly said they were closely monitoring global economic and financial developments. These were nice dovish additions but we thought that the dropping of “risks being balanced” and the reference to being “reasonably confident” about inflation returning to 2% was more telling.
The changes to the FOMC statement reinforced what the market had already discounted – that the Fed's four rate hikes, as laid out in December’s dot-plot, are a fantasy. Before all the market turmoil in January, the fed funds futures were pricing in just two rate increases by year-end. The market is currently pricing in a single hike this year and traders see a 16% chance that the Fed will raise rates at its March meeting, down from 51 percent at the start of this year.
Looking ahead, it will be another busy week in the currency markets. The first trading week in February will see the release of Chinese PMI, UK PMI, RBA Rate Decision, German Labor Report, NZ Labor Report, BoE Rate Decision & Quarterly Report, US Non-Farm Payrolls, and the Canadian Employment Report.
Wednesday, October 14, 2015
Ok CAD!
The CAD turned in another strong performance after leading the pack the previous week, however, caution is warranted after last Friday’s employment report. Like all currencies, the CAD has benefited from the US Fed’s dovish September hold. Another driver of the CAD’s advance has been the rebound in the economy. Back-to-back monthly GDP growth in June and July after five sequential months of negative or zero growth has help to cement expectations that the economy may have turned the corner and would not need any additional easing by the Bank of Canada. Of course, a discussion on the performance of the CAD would not be complete without any mention of the price of crude. Crude oil has managed to rally about 34% of its recent low in August and also managed to rise over the $50 level this past week before giving up some of its gains. Having said this, the way forward for Canada remains bumpy as evidenced by Friday’s jobs data. Canada added 12.1k jobs in the month of September, which was slightly better than expected. However, all of those gains were in part-time jobs since there was a loss of 61.9k full-time jobs, the largest amount since October 2011. That brings the loss in full-time jobs to 25K for Q3 alone. In addition, the unemployment rate rose to 7.1%, a 2-year high. This type of data warns that the rally in the CAD may sputter soon.
For the second consecutive week the USD has been the underperformer against the majors as the release of the FOMC minutes from the September meeting reinforced the dovish impression. The leaders of the pack, AUD and NZD, each managed to turn in a 4% increase on the week, powered by its own unique driver. The AUD surged higher after the Reserve Bank of Australia kept rates on hold as expected but it suggested that the bar was high for another rate cut this year. For the NZD, the story continued to be milk. Milk prices increased for the fourth auction in a row, fanning expectations that prices for New Zealand’s most important export have bottomed, which in turn takes the pressure off the Reserve Bank of New Zealand to ease again.We had no less than six FOMC members speaking last week and even though all 6 members are considered doves, they all went out of their way to impress upon us that an interest rate hike is coming soon and that they really, really, really mean it this time. Oh really?! They’re not the only ones trying to sell us this line. Apparently 64% of the economists surveyed by the Wall Street Journal expect a hike in December. To be a little fair, some of these economists have wavered from their original position because back in August, 82% expected a hike in September. The survey also found that 23% expect the first hike will be delivered in March 2016; do we hear anyone for 2017? We wonder if any of these economists are also employed at the IMF because they just downgraded global growth to 3.1% this year from its previous forecast of 3.3%. By the way, it was the fourth time this year that they changed their forecast. Are you kidding me? Why do we even listen to these people? Apparently, we are not the only ones with this opinion. Joris Luyendijk of the Guardian wrote an eloquent piece on the science of economics, or rather the lack thereof, this weekend titled, “Don’t let the Nobel prize fool you, Economics is not a science.”
We have our doubts. We don’t see a hike at all this year or next, which falls in line with many forecasters and analysts. But hey… what do we know? We’re not going to let the fact that for the first time since 2009, all six major Fed regional activity surveys are in contraction territory. We’re also going to ignore the fact that 3-month bills sold at a yield of zero for the first time in history. That’s right, at last Monday’s Treasury auction investors decided to buy $21 billion in 3-month Treasury bills at a yield of zero. If that didn’t astonish you, demand was the strongest in over three months, as the bid-to-cover ratio, which is a widely used measure of demand, was the highest since late June, according to data from Jefferies. Don’t worry folks, interest rates can’t go much lower than zero, or can they?
The USD has been the worst performing currency since the Fed decided to leave interest rate on hold at its September policy meeting. This weakening in the USD combined with the global slowdown in growth and lower inflation due to lower commodity prices is starting to undermine the current quantitative easing (QE) programs of the ECB and the BOJ. What we mean by undermine is that the euro and yen are rising against the USD. This may cause these central banks along with other foreign central banks to ease policy even further causing the USD to rise again. If this transpires, then the Fed may have to respond in kind in order to keep the USD in check (The ECB and BOJ can’t have this, there is a currency war going on after all). Many of the bloggers in cyberspace that are calling for QE4 have it all wrong. The fact that we have had more than one QE program from the Fed only tells us that they have all failed. We think the Fed’s next move will be not a hike in rates or another QE program, but a cut in interest rates to negative. Don’t think it’s possible? Well, let’s consider that the Swiss national bank is at negative 0.75%, the ECB is at negative 0.20%, and Sweden and Denmark are also in negative territory. Also, remember the September dot plot, which showed that one FOMC member wanted negative rates at the end of 2015 and 2016. We’re guessing that was Minneapolis Fed chief Narayana Kocherlakota because in a speech last Thursday he made these following points that were summarized by Bloomberg:
KOCHERLAKOTA SAYS FED SHOULD CONSIDER NEGATIVE RATES
KOCHERLAKOTA: TAPERING ASSET PURCHASES LED TO SLOWER JOB GAINS
KOCHERLAKOTA SAYS JOBS SLOWDOWN 'NOT SURPRISING' GIVEN POLICY
KOCHERLAKOTA: TAPERING ASSET PURCHASES LED TO SLOWER JOB GAINS
We would be remised if we didn’t mention the China factor in all of this. China’s foreign exchange reserves fell another $43bn last month, suggesting continued intervention in the forex markets to support the renminbi. This was down from the $94bn they spent in August trying to shore up the renminbi after the August 11 devaluation. Should we expect the Chinese to continue to spend their reserves on stopping their currency from falling while their economy continues to sputter? Wouldn’t it help China’s economy if they allowed the currency to fall? We suspect that if the Chinese renminbi does fall it will force the Fed to react and that reaction may very well be in the form of negative interest rates.
Posted by
VBCE FX
at
2:38 PM
0
comments
Labels:
AUD,
CAD,
China,
ECB,
GDP,
Interest Rate decision,
negative interest rate,
NZD,
QE,
US Federal Reserve
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



