Diminishing Returns

The carry trade continued to unwind last week. The Japanese yen, Swiss franc, and the euro have been used as funding currencies, due to their low or negative interest rates, were at the head of the pack. Market participants bought those currencies last week in order to exit their trades. The unwinding of the carry trade caused excessive volatility in financial markets. However, signs of stabilization in the equity markets were apparent in Friday’s price action. This was also reflected in the currency markets as the funding currency stopped rising and actually fell on Friday – perhaps signalling that the carry trade unwind had run its course, for now. We will know for sure as the new week opens and markets in most of Asia reopen after being closed for most of last week due to holidays.

It has been an extraordinary start to 2016. For the first couple of weeks the market’s anxiety revolved around the declines in the stock market and currency of China. It quickly changed to the oversupply of crude and its falling price. Then the market’s obsession turned to fears that the US economy was entering a recession. Before that obsession faded, along came the obsession of third party risk and troubled banks.

The financial sector is down about 15% year to date but Deutsche Bank is down more than 35% due to potential issues with its derivatives portfolio and its capital structure. Deutsche responded to the investor’s loss of confidence with a plan to back $5.4B in debt. The plan is so desperate it will even start buying back debt that was issued less than six weeks ago. Where have we seen this before? You got it – Lehman Brother in 2008. I guess we should have seen this coming back in June 2015 when the bank’s co-CEO, Anshu Jain and Jürgen Fitschen, abruptly resigned. We are not suggesting that this is 2008 all over again. However, sentiment has definitely changed since the Fed’s December rate hike as evidenced by the unwinding of carry trades.

Last week, Fed Chair Janet Yellen delivered a relatively upbeat assessment to the Senate Banking Committee. “A lot has happened” since December, when the Fed talked about raising rates 4 times in 2016 to kick off three years of sequential rate hikes, Yellen acknowledged. When asked about the risk of a recession, she responded that anything is possible but “expansions don’t die of old age.” She made clear that Fed officials were still debating when, not whether, they should raise rates again. She went on to play down the possibility that the Fed would seek to provide new stimulus by imposing negative interest rates. However, she refused to take negative interest rates off the table.

What we have here is a difference of opinion between the market and the central bank. The Fed expects the economy to continue to perform while it administers additional interest rate hikes; while investors expect the slowdown in the global economy will force the Fed to change course. The market is currently pricing in about an 8% chance that the Fed will lower rates by the end of 2016, compared with a 4% chance it will raise them, according to overnight-indexed swaps data compiled by Bloomberg.

Gold’s 16.76% rise year to date seems to reflect investors’ angst that central banks are out of ammo. The popular finance blog, Zero Hedge, recently put out a missive promoting that notion. They suggested that 8 years of monetary easing comprised of 637 collective rate cuts, $12.3 trillion in global quantitative easing, and with $8.3tn of global government debt currently yielding 0% or less

have been a “quantitative failure.” They insist that central banks have failed to revive the global economy and that every new measure yields less and less. They may be correct but we don’t think that central banks will stop. They continue to tell us that they have more tools in their tool box and we don’t doubt them – in fact, Ben Bernanke once talked about dropping money out of a helicopter. One thing that we are sure of is that every new tool used by central banks will lead to a corresponding move higher in the price of gold. Why you ask? – because Gold is the only currency that central bank can’t debase (create out of thin air).

It's Official: Canada is in Recession

It’s Official: Canada is in Recession

From Business Insider:

Canadian gross domestic product unexpectedly fell 0.2% in May. This was worse than the 0.0% expected by economists.

"The economy has contracted in six out of the last seven months," BNP's Derek Lindsay noted. The resource-rich economy has felt the crushing pain of falling commodity prices as global demand for raw materials has decelerated. And relief doesn't seem to be coming anytime soon.
"We continue to see falling commodities prices weighing heavily on the economy, with mining, utilities, and manufacturing presenting biggest drags on the goods side," Lindsay said. And this probably means more easy monetary policy.

"The Bank of Canada is likely to read this report as supportive of their move to cut rates at their last policy meeting earlier this month," Lindsay added. "We expect further easing ahead, as investment and exports remain in contractionary territory and the economy remains vulnerable to a correction in housing and a pullback in spending due to high levels of household debt."

Here are the specific details from Stancan:

Manufacturing output contracts

Manufacturing output contracted 1.7% in May, following no growth in April.
Durable-goods manufacturing fell 2.4% in May, as almost all major groups lost ground. Notable declines were recorded in machinery, computer and electronic products, fabricated metal products and miscellaneous manufacturing. Non-metallic mineral products manufacturing was up.
Non-durable goods manufacturing was down 0.7% in May, primarily because of declines in the manufacturing of food as well as beverage and tobacco. Decreases were also posted in textile, clothing and leather manufacturing, chemical manufacturing as well as printing and related support activities. The manufacturing of petroleum and coal products and of plastic and rubber products advanced.

Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction falls again

Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction fell 0.7% in May, down for a seventh consecutive month.
Oil and gas extraction fell 1.0% in May, after decreasing 3.4% in April, mainly as a result of a decline in conventional oil and natural gas extraction. Non-conventional oil extraction was also down.
Mining and quarrying (excluding oil and gas extraction) was down 0.8% in May. A decline in metallic mineral mining outweighed a gain in coal mining. Non-metallic mineral mining (which includes potash mines) was unchanged in May.
Support activities for mining and oil and gas extraction increased 2.8% in May, after rising 9.6% in April, as both drilling and rigging services advanced again. The gains in April and May followed double-digit declines in the first three months of the year.

Wholesale trade falls while retail trade rises

Following a 1.6% gain in April, wholesale trade fell 1.0% in May. Declines were notable in wholesaling of machinery, equipment and supplies, miscellaneous wholesaling (which includes agricultural supplies) as well as motor vehicle and parts wholesaling. On the other hand, food, beverage and tobacco wholesaling and farm products wholesaling were up.
Retail trade rose 0.5% in May after a 0.3% decline in April, led by increases in the activities of building material and garden equipment and supplies dealers as well as electronics and appliance stores.

Construction grows

Construction grew 1.0% in May, as engineering and repair construction as well as residential and non-residential building construction advanced.
The output of real estate agents and brokers rose 2.1% in May, up for a fourth consecutive month.
Finance and insurance sector declines
The finance and insurance sector declined 0.3% in May. A decrease in banking services outweighed increases in financial investment and insurance services.

Other industries

Utilities declined 1.4% in May, down for a third consecutive month. Electricity generation, transmission and distribution as well as natural gas distribution were both down in May. Unseasonably warm weather was recorded in some parts of the country in May.
The public sector (education, health and public administration combined) edged down 0.1% in May. Declines in educational and health care services more than offset an increase in public administration.
Accommodation and food services were up 0.9% in May, in parallel with an increase in the number of overnight travelers to Canada.

Need even more evidence?

Here are Five stages of death of the Canadian dollar according to the Globe and Mail which include Denial, Anger, Bargaining, Depression and finally Acceptance...

From BMO deputy chief economist Michael Gregory and senior economist Benjamin Reitzes:

"With a view to final trimester Fed tightening this year, unmatched by the BoC, we look for the currency to continue to depreciate, averaging C$1.33 in October [meaning about 75 cents]. Political uncertainty heading into the Oct. 19 federal election and continued global oil price volatility (but along sideways trend) should reinforce the weakening trend. Presuming the absence of post-election policy uncertainty and more oil prices, we look for the Loonie to average a cent or so stronger by 2015-end."

Other news...

The top performing currency last week was the Pound Sterling (GBP) but the excitement builds this week as we may see further gains in anticipation of the three PMI’s; Construction, Manufacturing and Services. In addition, it will be the first time the Bank of England will simultaneously release its policy decision, the meeting minutes, the votes and their new macroeconomic forecasts. Early last month BoE Governor, Mark Carney, had stated that, “the British economy's strong momentum meant the decision on when to raise rates would come into sharper focus around the end of this year.” Therefore, there is a strong possibility that there will be at least one vote for an interest rate hike.

The worst performer last week was the Swiss Franc (CHF). The SNB, Switzerland's central bank, reported a loss of 50.1 billion CHF on Friday due to a policy change. Per Business Insider, the bank's foreign currency reserves underwent a major devaluation when it decided to abandon a policy to cap the value of the franc against the euro earlier this year. Since the SNB had been buying Euros to maintain an exchange of 1.20 Swiss Francs to the Euro, it pushed up the value of the Franc, devaluing the recently bought Euros.

If you’re wondering why the US Federal announcement had little impact on the on the market last week, it might be because “staff projections prepared before the June 16-17 policy meeting were inadvertently included in a computer file that was posted to the Fed’s website on June 29.”
How’s that for a spoiler! The projections saw the federal-funds rate averaging 0.35% in Q4 of 2015, then rising to 1.26% in Q4 of 2016 and finally 2.12% in the fourth quarter of 2017. That’s one hike this year and potentially four next year. The actual statement however was quite lack luster, as the central bank only made small changes to its monetary policy, being very careful not to suggest when exactly they will raise interest rates this year; September or December. A September hike is the heavy favorite among banks, analysts and traders alike, but they may have missed something…

Trouble in Oceania

The Swiss franc nudged the USD out of first place last week despite the news that Switzerland's economy shrank in Q1 by 0.2%, which may foreshadow a brief pause in the USD’s rally after strong advance since mid-May. A combination of month-end flows and a six point drop in Friday’s release of the May Chicago PMI, to contraction territory at 46.2, encouraged USD bulls to take profits ahead of this week’s busy economic calendar. The releases include a central bank meeting in Australia, the UK, and Europe as well as OPEC's semi-annual meeting. The key economic events are the monthly global PMI readings, Eurozone flash CPI, and the U.S. nonfarm payroll report.

The worst performing currencies last week came from the two main countries in Oceania, Australia and New Zealand as their currencies fell 2.7% and 2.38% respectively. Both economies are dealing with the reduced demand from China for their main export product, iron ore for Australia and milk for New Zealand. Both currencies are being pulled down against the USD by the divergence in monetary policy. 

The AUD was weighed down by Wednesday’s release of private capital expenditure which came in at -4.4% versus -2.3% that was expected. The data reveals that Australia’s transition away from a mining-dominated economy remains challenging and is still some time away. The capex data is the weakest in five years and supports the Reserve Bank of Australia's decision to cut the official cash rate in February and possibly at this week’s upcoming meeting.

The NZD fell to a five year low against the USD on Friday and has shed about 6.5% since mid-May as investors wagered that interest rates in New Zealand and in the U.S. were set on a diverging course. The catalyst for the move was the release of the ANZ Business Outlook Survey which fell to 15.7 in May from April's reading of 30.2. The survey showed that inflation expectations were at an all-time low of 1.6% in May, which is below the Reserve Bank of New Zealand's (RBNZ) 2% target midpoint. The string of poor data and dairy price indications has increased pressure on the RBNZ to cut rates. The central bank’s next meeting is on June 10th.